Chapter Four: The Missing Pages

Perrin's house smelled like old paper and woodsmoke and something herbal that Corin had never identified and never asked about. It was a particular smell, specific to that house and no other, the kind that lodged in memory and stayed. Years later, Corin suspected, he would catch a thread of it somewhere — in a library, in a scholar's study — and be transported back to the low ceilings and crowded shelves and the old man's patient attention.

He came back on a Tuesday morning, when the forge had no urgent work and Bram had told him to take the time. He brought the book Perrin had lent him and his own rough notes and a set of questions he'd been sharpening since the night the lamp ran out of oil.

Perrin made tea without being asked and sat across the small table and listened while Corin explained what he wanted.

"More on the pre-Compact period," Perrin said. "Specifically connected to this symbol."

"Specifically anything from the high ranges, the period before the Houses organized the mountain territories. Whatever you have. Whatever refers to whatever else might exist."

Perrin looked at him over the rim of his cup. "You found the fragment in chapter four useful."

"I found it interesting. I want to know if there's more."

"There is always the question of whether more exists to be found." But he rose, because Perrin's natural condition was curiosity and Corin had handed him something to be curious about. "Let's see what we have."

What they had turned out to be more than Corin had expected and less than he needed, which was a combination that would define the next several hours.

Perrin's collection was not a library in the formal sense. It was the accumulated reading of a lifetime — books purchased, books borrowed and never returned, books given as gifts, books acquired in ways Perrin was vague about when asked. They covered the shelves in both rooms and spilled into stacks on the floor beside the shelves and occupied three chairs that had been surrendered to the purpose and never reclaimed. The organizing logic remained mysterious, but Perrin moved through it without hesitation, pulling volumes and replacing them and pulling others, occasionally stacking several on the table for Corin to examine while he went looking for something else.

They started with the mountain territories.

There was more material here than Corin had seen in chapter four. Three different volumes covered the pre-Compact settlements in various degrees of depth, and Perrin found two sets of hand-copied notes from a traveling scholar who had passed through the region a century ago and recorded what local communities still remembered of the early period. Corin read carefully, making his own notes, flagging references that seemed relevant.

The symbol didn't appear directly in any of it. But there were edges. References to marking systems used by the high-range communities — not the crude boundary stones of the lowland settlements but something more elaborate, a notation practice that the traveling scholar found intriguing and couldn't fully decipher. He had copied a few examples, small and rough, and Corin held his lamp close to the page and examined them. Two had the same quality he recognized from his own sketch. The same grammar, as Perrin had put it. The same precision of line.

"These notations," Corin said. "He tried to find out more about them?"

Perrin looked over his shoulder. "Let me see." He read the relevant passage. "He says here he was directed to a manuscript held at the Aldenmere archive. He called it — " he followed the line with his finger — "'a record of the early high-range markings compiled from the original sources, which I hope to consult on my return journey.'"

"Did he?"

Perrin turned several pages. "He doesn't mention it again." He frowned. "He may have changed his route. The notes end somewhat abruptly."

Corin wrote down: Aldenmere archive. Early high-range markings. Original sources. "Can we find the manuscript he mentioned? Is it indexed anywhere?"

"The Aldenmere archive maintains a catalog, or did. Whether I have a copy here — " Perrin went to one of the shelves and searched for a while. He came back with a thin bound document that looked like it had been assembled from several sources and stitched together at some earlier point. "This is a partial catalog. Perhaps thirty years old. It wouldn't include everything."

They went through it together, Perrin reading the entries in his methodical way while Corin followed and flagged anything that seemed connected. It took most of the morning.

They found three references to documents covering pre-Compact mountain records. Two of the entries listed the documents as available. One listed a note beside it in a different hand than the rest of the catalog.

Removed for review. See central record.

"What does that mean?" Corin asked.

Perrin looked at the entry for a long moment. "It usually means a document has been taken out of the archive's main collection for examination by a scholar or official, and a note is made in case someone comes looking. The central record would tell you who took it and when."

"And we don't have the central record."

"No. The catalog only." Perrin's frown had settled into something more considered. "It's not unusual, in itself. Documents move. They're borrowed, transferred, studied and returned, sometimes not returned. Archives are not always tidy places."

Corin looked at the entry. Then at the two others they'd flagged. "But the traveling scholar never mentioned the archive turning him away."

"He said he hoped to consult it. He may have been turned away and simply not recorded it. He may have consulted something else. He may have changed direction." Perrin took the catalog back and looked at the entry again. "What's bothering you, specifically?"

Corin wasn't sure he could explain it yet. It was the feeling rather than the proof — the sensation of pulling on a thread and finding it cut rather than following it somewhere. "He found a notation system in the high ranges that he couldn't explain. He was directed to a specific archive that might explain it. He never mentions it again. The document the archive held on the subject has been removed. And we can't find out where it went."

Perrin considered this. "That's three things in a row that lead nowhere."

"Four, if you count the partial symbol in your chapter four book, where the historian called it unknown origin and didn't appear to pursue it further."

"He may have pursued it and not included the conclusion in that volume."

"Did he write others?"

Perrin thought about it. "He may have. I only have the one." He looked at Corin over his spectacles with the expression of a man updating his assessment of a situation. "You're suggesting these absences aren't accidental."

"I'm not suggesting anything yet. I'm noticing a pattern."

"A pattern may be coincidence."

"It may be," Corin agreed. "That's why I want to keep looking."

After a midday break — bread and cold meat that Perrin produced from somewhere in the back of the house — they continued.

Perrin pulled a different category of material: histories of the Dragon Houses themselves, the period of consolidation when the Houses had organized the territories and established the Compact that still governed dragon-human relations. There were four or five volumes of varying quality, ranging from what was clearly official House-sponsored history to a more skeptical account by a scholar who seemed to have an axe to grind and ground it at length.

Corin read the skeptical one first.

It was interesting. The scholar — a woman from the southern territories writing perhaps a hundred and fifty years ago — had focused on what she called "the gaps in the consolidation record," the period immediately before the Compact when the Dragon Houses had moved to establish their authority across the mountain regions. She was focused on political history rather than symbols or markings, and her argument was about power and territory rather than anything Corin was looking for. But in a footnote on her third chapter she mentioned, almost in passing, that the pre-Compact records of the high mountain communities were "incomplete to a degree I find difficult to attribute entirely to natural loss," and cited three specific documents that she had been unable to locate in any archive.

She had tried to locate them in multiple places.

None of them had been findable.

Corin read the footnote twice. Then he copied the three titles into his notes and went back to the main text, looking for anything else she'd flagged.

There were two more mentions. Both footnotes. Both pointing at something she'd looked for and not found, in the context of the early consolidation period. Both expressed with the careful language of a scholar who knew the difference between lost and not there, and seemed increasingly unsure which category she was dealing with.

He brought the book to Perrin.

Perrin read the footnotes in question with the attention he gave everything. His expression cycled through several things that weren't quite words.

"She was a serious scholar," he said finally. "Soria Dren. I know her other work. Not inclined to conspiracy thinking."

"She doesn't say conspiracy. She says she can't explain the absence."

"Which is a careful distinction."

"Yes."

Perrin set the book down slowly. He looked at the stacks of material on the table with the expression of a man reviewing a conversation and finding that it had arrived somewhere he hadn't expected. "The documents she listed. Do you want me to check if I have references to any of them?"

"Please."

It took longer this time. Perrin went through three separate catalogs and his own handwritten index of sources he'd come across over the years. He found one reference to the first document on Soria Dren's list — a mountain territorial survey from before the Compact — in a general index of historical records he'd copied from the district seat library forty years ago.

The entry was present.

Below it, in different ink, was a single line.

Volume no longer held. Refer to central archive.

Corin looked at that for a long time.

"A different hand," he said. "Different ink."

"Added later. After the index was originally compiled." Perrin said it without particular inflection, but he was not, Corin noticed, dismissing it. "Could have been an update by the library's own catalogers. Could have been anyone with access to the index."

"Does the district seat library have a central archive?"

"Every substantial library does. Whether it's accessible — whether it's properly maintained — that varies considerably."

Corin leaned back in his chair and looked at the ceiling. Above him, the low wooden beams were hung with bundles of the dried herbs that contributed to the house's particular smell. Some of them were so old and dry they'd lost their color entirely, faded to the same pale brown. They had been there a long time.

"Can I show you something?" he asked.

He reached into his pocket and unwrapped the cloth and set the scale on the table.

He'd been carrying it all day. He hadn't planned to show it. But Perrin had spent four hours helping him trace absences across half a dozen sources, and something about the afternoon felt like it had earned a different kind of honesty.

Perrin looked at the scale. He leaned forward. He picked it up with both hands and examined it with the careful thoroughness of a man who understood that objects carried information as well as books did, sometimes more honestly.

"The mark is inside the surface," Corin said. "You need a very low raking light to see it. Like firelight at the right angle."

Perrin carried the scale to his hearth and crouched there for a long time without speaking. Corin waited. Outside the window, Ashvale carried on in its afternoon way — someone's cart on the main path, the sound of children somewhere near the well, the deep clear silence that lay underneath everything in the mountains, the silence that was always there if you listened past the surface noise.

"There," Perrin said quietly, to himself.

A moment passed.

"The symbol your sketch was based on," Perrin said, from his position by the hearth. He hadn't turned around. "If this is what I think I'm looking at — the origin of that symbol — then this object is very old. Older than anything I've held before."

"Older than the Houses?"

"The Houses are three hundred years old at most. I mean older than that by an order of magnitude, if the grain of this material is what it appears to be." He rose carefully and came back to the table and set the scale down. "I would want a mineralogist to confirm it. Or a naturalist. Someone with the right expertise. I'm a schoolmaster and a reader, not a specialist."

"But you think it's old."

"I think it's very old." He looked at the scale and then at Corin. "And the mark inside it connects to symbols found in the high mountain ranges before any records we can currently access. Records that appear to have been — " he searched for the word — "withdrawn from availability."

Not lost.

Not damaged.

Withdrawn.

Corin watched him arrive at that word and not take it back.

"That's strange," Perrin said, almost to himself. It was the tone of a man who had spent a lifetime around information and knew what its absence signified. "That's genuinely strange. A systematic absence — not every record from the period, nothing so obvious as that, but specifically the records that might illuminate this particular area of history." He looked at Corin. "Someone would need access to do that."

"Access and reason."

"Yes." He was quiet for a moment. "I won't pretend I have an explanation. I don't. It may have a mundane one I haven't thought of. But I'd want to find the central archive at the district seat and see what it contains — or what it doesn't contain. That would tell us more than what I have here." He looked at Corin steadily. "I assume you have a reason for pursuing this."

"I found the scale. I want to understand what it is."

"A reasonable impulse." Perrin picked up his tea, which had gone cold, and didn't drink it. "Be careful with that object, Corin. Whatever it is, it's old enough that other people may have opinions about it."

It was, Corin thought, the second time in less than two weeks that someone had told him to be careful. The first time it had been Garran, who had known immediately what he was looking at. Now Perrin, who barely knew, was arriving at the same warning from a completely different direction.

He wrapped the scale back in its cloth and put it in his pocket.

"The books Soria Dren couldn't find," he said. "If they're not in any archive she could access — where would they go?"

Perrin set his cup down. "Records that are removed from accessibility — officially, through proper channels — usually go to a central collection. Under the care of whoever has the authority to move them." He looked at the window. "In this region, that authority has historically rested with the Dragon Houses."

Corin looked at him.

"I'm not suggesting anything," Perrin said, with the exact phrasing Corin had used earlier in the day. "I'm describing how archival authority works. Who holds it, and who doesn't."

"Who removes documents and who doesn't."

Perrin met his eyes. "Yes."

Bram was finishing a late piece of work when Corin returned, a lamp lit against the early dark that came in autumn, the forge settling into its evening sounds. He looked up when Corin came in, assessed him with the glance that ten years of shared life had made accurate, and went back to his work.

"You were with Perrin all day," he said.

"Yes."

"Find anything?"

Corin took off his coat and hung it on the peg. The scale was still in the pocket. He could feel its warmth from across the room, or told himself he could. "Enough to find more questions."

Bram set down his tongs. He turned to face Corin fully, which was a thing he didn't do unless he meant it. "I've watched you go somewhere in your head this last week and a half and not come back. I'm not asking you to stop. I know better. But I'm asking you to tell me honestly — is this the kind of question you can walk away from if it becomes dangerous? Or is it the kind that'll carry you somewhere you didn't plan to go?"

The fire moved in the coals. The lamp made a small steady sound.

Corin thought about the chain of absences he and Perrin had followed across six sources and an afternoon. The catalog entries pointing nowhere. The footnotes of a serious scholar who hadn't been able to explain what was missing. The document that had been withdrawn and sent somewhere with authority over such things.

The symbol. The scale. The warmth that never stopped.

"I don't know yet," he said.

Bram looked at him for a moment. Then he nodded, because it was an honest answer and Bram valued honest answers above comfortable ones.

"Then be careful while you find out," he said, and picked up his tongs.

That night Corin sat at the workbench with his notes spread in front of him and the lamp at its lowest useful setting, and he looked at what he had.

The mark existed. It had appeared in the high mountain ranges before any Dragon House, before the Compact, before any record the current archives preserved in full. It was old enough that the grain of the scale that bore it made Perrin — a man who did not dramatize — say order of magnitude with a careful face.

And the records that might explain it were gone. Not lost in the way that things were lost to time and fire and neglect. Gone in a way that left traces — catalog entries, footnotes, the bewilderment of a serious scholar trying to find sources she had reason to believe existed. Gone in a way that required access. Gone in a way that had a direction.

He looked at his sketch of the mark.

He had been wrong about what he was looking for.

He'd thought the symbol was the mystery. The thing to be decoded, identified, sourced and explained. He'd spent a week imagining the answer as a definition — this symbol means this, it belonged to this, here is what it signifies.

But the symbol was just the thread. And when he'd pulled it, he hadn't found what the thread connected to.

He'd found the place where someone had cut it.

The lamp guttered. Outside, the mountain dark was complete and quiet, no wind, no storm, just the deep cold silence of the high places.

The missing records were the mystery.

And someone had made them missing.

Subscribe to our newsletter

"Some worlds are waiting to be found."